Marketing speak, when it comes to system uptime or downtime, can be misleading. Learn some basic relationships between your “nines” of downtime to be ready.

It’s easy to believe slick marketing speak, when discussing system uptime, downtime or availability. System design for maximum business availability, and the skillful maintenance required therein, are complex and difficult topics.

Most businesses don’t have unlimited budgets to put toward keeping systems available, so it’s always a balance between your spend, difficulty of maintenance, and the business risk involved with downtime. It’s case by case.

Indeed, if you are doing your job right as a sysadmin, keeping your systems up and running without incident, people think it must be easy because there are no problems. You’re only noticed when something goes wrong.

What’s the scoop on uptime and downtime?

Uptime is, strictly speaking, the percentage a system is “running”, and downtime is the inverse of that. However, the key thing to follow is “availability”, which is a measurement of whether a system’s target users can access and normally use a system.

A system can be “up” but unavailable, so when defining SLAs or “working agreements” with businesses, it is best to focus on availability guarantees and not just simple uptime.

But availability is a more complex calculation, so let me simplify to just talk about downtime and uptime.

System Downtimes as Percentages & Durations

I put together the handy spreadsheet below, to show the number relationships between amounts of downtime. A few points to note about this sheet:

  • I assume an average days per year of 365.25 accounting for leap years. Mins / month is pretty different if you calculate at 365 vs 365.25.
  • I list “marketing” uptime as six nines, five nines, four nines and so on. Notice the marketing terms cover a range of downtime. For example, four nines is anywhere from 27 sec to just under 15 min / month. A user might not even notice 27 seconds, but 15 min will likely be noticed.
  • The difference between six & five nines, 5 & 4, 4 & 3, 3 & 2, and 2 & 1 nines, is 10 times the downtime in each case. Six nines is 2.63 sec / month down, whereas five nines is 26.30 sec / month down.
Figure: System Downtimes as Percentages and Durations

I hope you can find some value in knowing these ranges and number relationships, when you are discussing system uptime. But the hard work of figuring out how to keep systems available still has to be done, and in the most practical way possible.

Photo - 'Do Not Unplug' as an Availability Method, by Rick Cogley
Photo: 'Do Not Unplug' as an Availability Method, by Rick Cogley
Photo - 'Do Not Unplug' as an Availability Method, by Rick Cogley
Photo: 'Do Not Unplug' as an Availability Method, by Rick Cogley

Then again, you could just put a sign on it saying “don’t unplug” like this one from my hall of shame. But I hope you don’t.

Acknowledgements:

The banner photo is a photo of “hashioki” chopstick props that you balance your chopsticks on during a meal. I shot this at Roppongi Robataya. Original is here.